Myth or reality
Fact, but not necessarily for the reasons one might initially imagine. Science suggests that the context of use, individual beliefs and expectations, as well as the pleasure derived from the experience, could play a role just as important (if not more so) than the inhaled essential oil itself in the anti-stress effect felt. The effectiveness of this method could therefore be highly subjective.
What is true
Yes, smells trigger an emotional and physiological response.
Yes, certain essential oils are associated with a reduction in perceived stress.
Psychology, individual expectations and context play an underestimated role.
What is false
No, there is no evidence that essential oils are effective on their own.
Smell is not necessarily the dominant sense in the relaxation effect achieved.
There is no inhalation protocol that guarantees universal anti-stress efficacy.
Food for thought
Some of the benefits of inhaling essential oils for stress are likely to be based on a placebo effect. It would, however, be a shame to reduce this placebo effect to a mere illusion created by our brain or to a ‘false’ efficacy; on the contrary, science has proven that it is based on genuine cognitive, chemical and emotional mechanisms, which are subsequently maintained and reproduced through conditioning. Researchers refer in particular to the activation of the prefrontal cortex, the release of endorphins and dopamine, and a reduction in amygdala activity linked to anxiety.
This placebo effect, which some might dismiss, actually reminds us that our bodies are perfectly capable of modulating their own response to stress, provided we give them the chance.
This is a phenomenon also found in meditation, traditionally recommended for people experiencing stress, and whose benefits appear to be amplified by initial expectations (8). A 2023 study even managed to demonstrate that people who believe they have a tool designed to help them regulate their emotions more effectively do indeed develop better emotional regulation. Yet the tool in question is entirely fictional: it does not exist (9).
In short, if you believe it will work, you increase your chances of it working. Beyond mere stress management, this is a wonderful philosophy of life to apply to your everyday routine.